Carlton Traditional Style Homes for Sale

Take a step back in time when life was simpler and homes were built with integrity and true craftsmanship. 670 South Railroad Avenue is an historic c. 1917 farmhouse sited on 2.43 acres. If you’ve been searching for a manageable plot of land for homesteading and gardening, this adorable “Farmette” might be the perfect fit! Beautifully restored to honor the character and craftsmanship of yesteryear, there are many special features at every turn. The wrap-around front porch with granite masonry knee walls and stairs is a classic “Southernism” perfect for sweet tea sipping. The original front door still has its skeleton key and leads to the spacious living room complete with coffered ceiling, original fireplace and mantel, several large, wavy glass windows, and heart of pine floors that run throughout the home. A formal dining room features original corner built-in china cabinet, fireplace, pocket doors, and triple window that floods the room with light. With a door to the front porch, you could easily transition dinners outside in the cooler months. A butler’s pantry with custom cabinetry and granite countertops leads to the oh-so-adorable kitchen that has been updated yet still honors the stylings of the era the home was constructed. From the antique farm sink and faucet to the updated cabinetry and stainless appliances, you’ll have everything you need. A wide center hallway leads to the the Primary Suite which is quite spacious and features its own fireplace, 12ft ceilings, picture molding, and attached half bathroom. A full hall bathroom has been updated with custom tied shower. At the rear of the home, you’ll find the bright laundry room as well as the third bedroom. A quaint deck overlooks the backyard complete with two sizable workshops/ storage buildings (24X24 and 20X30), chicken coup, fenced vegetable garden, and possibilities galore! Horses are also permitted! Major updates include a new HVAC system with ductwork (2023), new water heater, updated plumbing, and fresh paint. Located a stones throw from Watson Mill State Park, with a short drive to shopping and dining and an easy commute to Athens. Find all of your antique furnishings, knickknacks, and odds ’n ends at Neat Pieces Antiques just down the road. This is a well-loved homeplace for the avid gardener, a small farmer, or someone wishing to escape life in the city!

670 S Railroad Ave, Carlton

$429,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 10731440 MLS

Step into timeless charm paired with modern luxury in this stunning newly built home-already the talk of the town. Tucked just outside Carlton, this distinctive residence beautifully blends the character of a classic country cottage with thoughtfully curated contemporary design. From the moment you arrive, the inviting front porch sets the tone-perfect for morning coffee or relaxed evenings with neighbors. Inside, the open-concept layout is filled with natural light and showcases exceptional craftsmanship throughout. Modern lighting and spa-inspired bathrooms add a touch of everyday elegance. The kitchen is both stylish and functional, featuring quartz countertops, custom cabinetry, and stainless steel appliances-ideal for daily living and effortless entertaining. Each bedroom offers a spacious retreat, combining the serenity of country living with the comforts of modern design. Out back, a private yard provides the perfect setting to relax, garden, or host gatherings-offering the peace and privacy you've been looking for. Come experience the home everyone is talking about.

825 New Town Church Road, Carlton

$429,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ CL353525 MLS

Step into timeless charm paired with modern luxury in this stunning newly built home—already the talk of the town. Tucked just outside Carlton, this distinctive residence beautifully blends the character of a classic country cottage with thoughtfully curated contemporary design. From the moment you arrive, the inviting front porch sets the tone—perfect for morning coffee or relaxed evenings with neighbors. Inside, the open-concept layout is filled with natural light and showcases exceptional craftsmanship throughout. Modern lighting and spa-inspired bathrooms add a touch of everyday elegance. The kitchen is both stylish and functional, featuring quartz countertops, custom cabinetry, and stainless steel appliances—ideal for daily living and effortless entertaining. Each bedroom offers a spacious retreat, combining the serenity of country living with the comforts of modern design. Out back, a private yard provides the perfect setting to relax, garden, or host gatherings—offering the peace and privacy you’ve been looking for. Come experience the home everyone is talking about.

825 New Town Church Rd, Carlton

$315,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ CM1013938 MLS

Take the long meandering drive to your private, wooded oasis on 12+acres! This cottage-style home boasts cozy wood paneling throughout and an open concept living plan! Natural light floods the home including the well appointed kitchen featuring granite counters, stainless appliances, subway tile backsplash and kitchen island. Laundry is a breeze in the cute dedicated laundry area hidden behind a beautiful, custom barn door! The Primary suite is spacious and serviced by its own private en suite bathroom. The additional bedroom is very cute. There's a secondary bathroom for guests as well. You'll enjoy endless hours of relaxation on the back deck overlooking your property which is ripe with possibilities from hiking, trail riding to gardening or even a hobby farm! Some of the property is fenced already for animals and additional outbuildings including a 12x20 utility shed are ready for your smaller farm animals or storage. The detached two car garage/shop is 30x30 and the perfect place to house all of your toys too! Come make this your little piece of paradise!

168 Elm Rd, Carlton

$455,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ CM1023093 MLS

Looking for privacy and to get away from the busy lifestyle. This farmhouse offers an open floor plan with ten foot ceilings throughout the home with eight foot doors to every room. Black Forest leathered granite throughout the home with soft close cabinetry in the kitchen and baths. Large stone fire place in the great room. You can look at the stone fireplace on the Lanai through your French doors in the Owners suite. The backyard is fenced. A 3 car garage offers additional enclosures for your extra cars or if you just want additional storage on the outside of your home.

180 Broad River Rd, Carlton

$620,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 10512908 MLS

Country living at its finest! Tranquil and secluded property in Madison County, tucked away on 12.14 acres. This private property features a rolling grassy meadow-like front yard as well as lots of trees and woods. Travel up the winding driveway that leads to this 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath country farmhouse. The stunning wrap-around front porch is perfect for watching the sunrise. The front porch pillars have been recently painted, and all three porches have been recently stained. The large foyer welcomes you and offers the first glimpse of the gorgeous hardwood floors. A large office is just off the foyer. You immediately notice that it's bathed in light from the extra-large windows and two French doors that lead to the wrap-around front porch. The open concept living room has vaulted ceilings, a gas fireplace with a granite surround and beautiful built-in custom shelves. Expansive, eat-in kitchen has granite counter tops and stainless appliances. The bright sunroom boasts a gorgeous wall of windows and tiled floors. The main floor features 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths. The light and airy master bedroom has 4 French doors that lead to the sunroom, master bath and a private porch. No detail was overlooked in this room that also features trey ceilings, a large walk-in closet, walk-in double shower, separate tub, and large double vanities. The upstairs features another large bedroom and full bath. This room could also be used as a bonus room, office or playroom for the kids. The spacious laundry room has plenty of storage and features a built-in desk with a granite countertop. The home has a two-car garage and two back porches that could easily be screened-in. There's a detached 30' x 40' workshop with power that offers unlimited possibilities for use. This home is 23 miles to downtown Athens - just close enough to commute and enjoy all this unique town has to offer, yet far enough away to experience peace and quiet. Come enjoy this serene property!

229 Deer Haven Run, Carlton

$699,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 10423025 MLS

Hunting Hill Farm is a captivating 4+ acre, 2 home property that perfectly marries historic charm with modern conveniences. The main house, a stunning two-story structure built in the late 1800s, boasts four bedrooms and three and a half baths. In the morning, walk out onto one of your expansive wrap-around porches to enjoy coffee, the beautiful views, and to look out on your horses in the paddock or one of the two irrigated pastures surrounded by attractive and functional four board fencing. Your home has been lovingly and carefully renovated and features an updated Kitchen, new appliances and granite countertops, updated Bathrooms, Laundry Room, and all of the modern amenities, while still preserving its classic look and feel. As you enter, the huge 12-foot coffered ceilings and wide wood-framed doorways provide a sense of grandeur. The beautifully finished wood floors, the wide, crown molding, the original doors and fixtures, even the ceilings themselves, reflect the incredible quality construction of a bygone era. There is a fireplace in the Master Bedroom as well as the large Master Bath, which also features a soaking tub and steam shower. Double French Doors lead from the Bath onto the wraparound side Porch. There is an additional Bedroom and Bathroom that opens onto the Hall, where a Staircase leads up to a Foyer/Landing. Upstairs, two Bedrooms and a half Bath also open onto the Landing. You will feel secure, not only in the quality of your turn of the century home, but from the lifetime warranties on its reinforced foundation and energy-efficient, and noise-reducing, double-paned windows. Behind the main house is a separate two-stall barn with lockable equipment bays and workshop. The adjacent paddocks provide ample space for horses or other livestock. The barn features a Ralph Lauren style Lounge (Tack Room), Feed Room, and Hayloft. There is ample room inside the barn (but outside the stall doors) to care for your horses, even in the worst weather. Across from the main house, with separate access and driveway, is a charming two-bedroom, one bath "Barndominium," great for guests, friends, relatives, or as an income producing asset. Built for local schoolteachers, around the same time as Main House, the second home includes the same quality wood construction and updated Kitchen and Bathroom and refinished wood floors found in the Main House. There are also two large adjoining horse stalls and a pasture. Best of all, this property is located in Carlton, a historic and friendly small town, less than thirty minutes from Athens, home to a large and welcoming equestrian community, only a half mile from 12 miles of equestrian trails at Watson Mill State Park, half an hour from most Shakerag fixtures, 1 hour from Belle Meade Hunt, and saddle clubs, close to world class arena and show facilities, close to the UGA Vet School, and within the desirable Madison County School System. Hunting Hill Farm is an ideal retreat for those seeking a blend of pastoral beauty and refined living. You must see it in person to understand just what a treasure it is. Note: the property for sale is composed of three lots located at 127 North Street, 5391 Highway 72 E, and 5435 Highway 72 E. An additional adjacent cottage at 87 North St. is listed separately.

127 North Street, Carlton

$455,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 10333932 MLS

Looking for privacy and to get away from the busy lifestyle. This farmhouse offers an open floor plan with ten foot ceilings throughout the home with eight foot doors to every room. Black Forest leathered granite throughout the home with soft close cabinetry in the kitchen and baths. Large stone fire place in the great room. You can look at the stone fireplace on the Lanai through your French doors in the Owners suite. The backyard is fenced. A 3 car garage offers additional enclosures for your extra cars or if you just want additional storage on the outside of your home.

180 Broad River Road, Carlton

$269,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 20157300 MLS

This house is so cute full of natural light and tons of upgrades!!There are 2 bedrooms PLUS an Office ,could be a nursery or small bedroom. There are 2 full baths as well. EVERYTHING in the interior of the house is NEW. From the flooring system, walls, plumbing, electrical, HVAC, windows, flooring, both bathrooms, water heater, kitchen and light fixtures. The designer finishes are gorgeous! When you walk in you will notice the beam that runs the width of the house the kitchen is open and bright with a huge island. The cabinets are white and the oversized island is blue with white quartz countertops and a stunning backsplash. The tile surrounding the fireplace pulls in that blue and it is a perfect design element. The master bathroom has an extra large walk in tiled shower, tiled floors and double vanity. The secondary bathroom has a gorgeous tile surround, tile floors and beautiful details. This is a great first home or investment property.

824 Lexington Carlton Road, Carlton

$220,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 20156440 MLS

This charming 1925 bungalow home has been well cared for and updated. It sits on a quiet street on a private lot. The master bedroom and bath are very spacious with two additional large bedrooms all on one level with a very large living room and kitchen. The mud room has tons of space for a freezer and shelving for storage. The laundry has its own separate space with a sink, a counter for folding and a lot of storage that can be closed off when not in use. This home is a must see to truly appreciate.

1376 S Railroad Avenue, Carlton

$495,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 10217150 MLS

Historical meets contemporary in this uniquely designed beauty! Combining historical colonial style with a gorgeous 2013 addition, this home has a footprint that is one-of-a-kind. Featuring 5 bedrooms & 6 full baths this spacious design has incredible possibility. Boasting a beautifully built kitchen with gas range, marble countertops, walk-in pantry, built-in refrigerator, and abundant counter and cabinet space. Open view to the family room including upgraded hardwood floors, fireplace, LED lighting, full guest bathroom and separate laundry and mud rooms. Bright and lovely multi-purpose studio space above the garage with private library, fireplace, office and full bathroom. Great for a dedicated secluded creative space or as an additional living area for guests. Two additional private living rooms with fireplaces, full office space with private entry, sun room with attached deck and in-law suite with full kitchen and bath. Beautifully landscaped yards, two car garage with ample extra parking space as well and 2 separate out buildings for additional storage or potentially income-producing! Schedule your tour today!

2715 Elberton Road, Carlton

$275,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 10199879 MLS

You'll see yourself coming home to 9 Elton Stewart Road. Three acres sliced from the corner of Lexington Carlton Road and Elton Stewart Road puts this adorable 3BR 2BA home on a prime piece of property in Oglethorpe County, close to schools and convenient to Athens. A welcoming, traditional layout, this home has that cozy ambiance you're looking for. The kitchen is light and bright with white cabinets and a lovely stone backsplash. The laundry and garage are just off the kitchen, as is your dining room with deck access to the expansive back yard. Two bedrooms on one side of the home are separated from the owners suite by your family room. Outside, abundant yard space with a fenced area for your four-legged friends makes for lots of opportunities for entertainment. The firepit will be a favorite lounging place as you sit back and star gaze. Come and fall in love! * New roof just 2 years old!

9 Elton Stewart Road, Carlton

$505,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 10183443 MLS

LEAVE YOUR TROUBLES BEHIND WITH A SLICE OF HEAVEN. The most perfect farm cottage with a detached 2 bay garage with a bedroom for guests all on 18 acres. Located an easy 30 minute drive from downtown Athens this charming 3 bedroom, 2 bath home was built from the ground up with not just love and attention to every detail but actually wood finishes from trees harvested from the 18 acres. Walk in from the front porch to the WOW of the great room, kitchen, dining area. A vaulted wood ceiling, brick fireplace, butcher block countertops and wood flooring finish off the social hub of the whole family...where you eat, where you hang out, the go-to-place for almost everything. The owners suite is to the right and is light and bright. Oversized windows allow for great views and bring the outside in. The ensuite hosts a low threshold tile shower. The additional 2 bedrooms are to the left of the great room and share a full bath. The covered backporch is perfect for unwinding, quiet and free from disturbances. Overlooking the wide open spaces, a perfect playground, garden, or start your mini-farm with fencing and livestock. The 26 x 44 garage not only has great storage, and a 2 bay garage and work space but also hosts a flex room with endless opportunities, currently serving as a cozy guest room and home gym. Owning your own private paradise is great,whether for a primary residence or a weekend retreat plus it allows for the enjoyment of nature. The Broad River, one of Georgias last free-flowing rivers is nearby and offers fishing fun, kayaking and rafting. Or enjoy hiking, camping, horseback riding and fun playing in the shoals at Watson Mill Bridge State Park just 10 minutes away. And for more outdoor fun, Richard B Russell State Park on Lake Russell is less than 30 minutes! Shopping, medical facilities and eateries also nearby for daily needs. 2105 River Road allows you to BREATHE!

2105 River Road, Carlton

View All Carlton GA Traditional Style Home Listings